Finally, the cigar menu, though not huge, has a pretty good selection of cigars. Third, the cocktails are delicious and the small plates menu looks good (we didn't order any food as we went here for drinks before a dinner reservation nearby). Second, the service is quite good - friendly without being intrusive. First, the atmosphere is beautiful, evoking an earlier time, with beautiful traditional leather, wood, upholstered furnitureĪnd decor evoking the 1920s or earlier. If you are a cigar lover, or married to one like I am, the Carnegie Club is the spot for you in Manhattan.